| With
the growth of high-definition TV comes the need for interconnects capable of handling
the massive amount of digital data between components. The cable of choice for
this task, largely driven by the consumer electronics industry, is HDMI. Addressing
the needs of both the content providers and the consumer, HDMI cables have become
the new digital link that provides the vital data between source and display components.
Unlike many of the older digital cables used solely for audio, HDMI cables carry
both high bandwidth video and audio. HDMI was born out of the older DVI specification
used for computer PC video. The latest HDMI 1.3 specification calls for significantly
higher bandwidth requirements (10.2Gb/s total or 340MHz per channel) than the
earlier versions due to an increase in resolution, color depth, and frame rates.
As resolutions increase from 720p and 1080i to 1080p, so does the need for signal
bandwidth. In addition, the HDMI specification also supports Deep Color,
which allows the source to double the number of bits allocated for each color
component. Additional features include support of higher frame rates (120Hz),
although no one that I know has yet made use of this feature. There is also new
audio support for Dolby's TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio standards, which offers
up to eight discrete channels with superior audio quality when used with compatible
audio decoders.
With
all these wonderful improvements in consumer video, come the significantly higher
data rate requirements. Unfortunately, many HDMI cables that might have worked
fine in the past (at 720p or 1080i rates), fail to meet the performance requirements
for the HDMI 1.3 standard. There are many HDMI cables available from a variety
of manufacturers, yet a large number of them do not perform at the higher data
rates, resulting is visible picture artifacts. To make matters worse, ceiling
mounted projectors typically require long cable runs, making it difficult for
installers to find a solution. The concern is real and we have seen the results
in our home theater system. Several of the HDMI cables that we have used at 1080i
rates, fail to perform consistently when pushed to 1080p, resulting in speckles
or even loss of synchronization in some cases. To
address this problem, a company called VizionWare has launched a new breed
of high performance HDMI cables for the A/V industry. Originally founded by Ken
Egan (the company's current Chief Technology Officer), VizionWare has developed
it's core digital technology in silicon and that has found its way into their
new HDMI product line. Unlike passive HDMI cables that rely on fancy gold-plated
contacts and exotic wire, VizionWare's Hi Wirez cable design takes
a system level approach to the problem to increase performance. The company solves
a variety of issues that plague current HDMI cable designs by leveraging from
some very innovative technologies core to the company's array of patents, many
of which are pending.
Conventional passive HDMI cables suffer from poor signal amplitude and phase dispersion
throughout the cable, especially as the cable length increases. The result is
signal attenuation which prevents the reliable transfer of data, and which ultimately
affects picture quality. Active electronics in the Hi Wirez cable plays
a key role in the performance margin gained by their design. HDMI/DVI signals
are specified as CML (Current Mode Logic) signaling that only sinks current to
one half of the true and complement differential pair at any given time. This
asymmetric drive causes common mode radiation and load differences in the cable.
The Hi Wirez cable design regenerates the source CML signals into a modified
LVDS (Low Voltage Differential Signaling), a truly symmetrical and balanced drive.
VizionWare's signal balancing and equalization techniques allow the data
to be sent over longer runs with excellent data recovery at the other end of the
cable. Once the data is recovered at the destination end of the cable, the data
is then converted back into CML signaling for full HDMI signal compatibility.
The Hi Wirez cable also implements advanced coding techniques they call
Optimal Spectral Diffusion to reduce the spectral energy induced
by horizontal and vertical (HSYNC & VSYNC) synchronizing coding
symbols. This Transition Density Management improves the BER (Bit Error
Rate) and reduces the probability of EMI. The result is an HDMI cable design that
works well over long lengths with plenty of noise margin. The
Hi Wirez HDMI cable fully supports 1080p, 1080i, 720p, 540p, 480p, and 480i resolutions
and is available in 1m, 2m, 5m, 7m, 10m, 15m, and 20m lengths. Eye-Diagram
Eye-Diagrams (also called Eye-Patterns) are a tools used by engineers to
evaluate the performance of a digital signal. While a single snapshot of a waveform
shows the behavior at that given time, the eye-diagram displays many samples of
the signal accumulated on top of one another. The result is a picture that shows
the nature of the signal being examined. The space around the light-blue mask
is an indication of the noise margin. Any bad sample will show up on the display
making it easier to identify problems with the interconnect. Below are some pictures
taken with a high performance Tektronix TDS684 digital storage oscilloscope.
 |
 |
| Courtesy
of Ken Egan at VizionWare (Tektronix TDS6804) |
Passive
Cables The waveforms shown here represent the performance characteristics
of a typical passive HDMI cable. This 5-meter cable uses 24 gauge twisted-pair
wires to carry the signals from one connector to the other. In this example, the
eye diagram is showing signs of high level attenuation. As the eye closes around
the MASK (light-blue area), data errors will begin to occur resulting in picture
artifacts and/or a complete loss of signal. Due to the slow rise and fall times,
jitter increases substantially as seen in the lower photo. In this example, the
cable does not meet the performance requirements needed for a reliable picture,
which also contributes to the small eye opening. In this example, artifacts would
likely be present on the display. While passive cables lack some of the advantages
of the active designs, other factors also contribute to performance degradation.
Poor termination methods with impedance discontinuities and intra-pair skew (differences
in electrical lengths of a pair) lead to signal reflections and jitter. In theory,
cables are merely transmission lines and need to be designed as such. Unfortunately,
in practice it is not always that easy to do.
 |
 |
Courtesy
of Ken Egan at VizionWare (Tektronix TDS6804) |
Active
Cables VizionWare's Hi Wirez active cable design have the
following performance characteristics with a similar 5-meter length. This cable
uses smaller 30 gauge twisted-pair wire, which accounts for the smaller diameter
and more flexible cable construction. The top photo shows an open eye with
a good amount of margin around the mask (light-blue area), which will ensure
that the received data can be easily recovered. As indicated from the photos,
the rise and fall times are very fast and the active equalization helps minimize
the transition time. Similarly, the lower photo shows a cumulative collection
of rising edge samples of the signal. The tightly controlled edge results in a
signal with low jitter. Even with a much longer Hi Wirez cable (15-meters
in our case), the electrical signals exhibit an open eye with minimal jitter and
plenty of margin. Setup
and Performance Our system utilizes the new Mitsubishi HC5000 Full-HD
1080p projector. The physical distance of the projector from our external video
processor is around 15-meters, the exact length of our review cable. This made
it a perfect test vehicle to evaluate the performance of the Hi Wirez active
HDMI cable design. Our source material came from a Sony PlayStation3 (PS3), which
is the first consumer product to meet the new HDMI 1.3 specification. Using the
PS3 as a source, our Blu-ray movies were played in full 1080p along with some
of the new video games. Other sources in our system were upconverted to 1080p
using our DVDO iScan HD+ video processor. For the purposes of this review, we
connected the 15-meter Hi Wirez HDMI cable directly from the PS3 to the
HC5000 projector with no inline switching. VizionWare
provides an AC power adapter with the Hi
Wirez HDMI cable that is designed to input power from either end of the cable,
depending upon where power is most easily available. The linear power adapter
(lower noise) provides 6VDC at 700mA with the center pin positive. We connected
the AC adapter on the transmitting end of the cable as it was more convenient
for us to get power there. We
started viewing some Blu-ray DVDs from our sample collection. Black Hawk Down
and Talladega Nights were the first movies to be watched. We have only
been watching 1080p for a couple of months now and it is a significant improvement
over 720p. Picture quality is spectacular in full 1920 x 1080 resolution with
no visible artifacts contributed by the Hi Wirez cable. That is not to
say there are no artifacts in these pictures, just not anything we can say came
from the cable itself. In comparison, some of our earlier HDMI cables most certainly
exhibited problems when pushed into the 1080p arena. One of our longer cables
produced speckles around high contrast areas while another exhibited intermittent
loss of video synchronization during playback. As with many movie transfers, there
are usually some subtle, yet visible artifacts that are the result of the telecine
(film-to-video) process, which are usually due to compression and/or low level
noise or grain in the picture. This is something we have noticed even in the early
transfers of the D-Theater D-VHS tapes. The trick is to identify issues related
to the cable itself. In our test, we found absolutely no problems with the Hi
Wirez HDMI cable. What
really impressed us with this cable was the new PlayStation3 games, such as NBA
07 featuring full 1080p at 60 frames per second. The PS3 has incredible processing
power and these games unleash vivid colors and with extremely high resolution
and fast action. While I haven't been a gamer for quite a long time, it is apparent
that our kids are now spoiled with the new products. We can see why HDMI 1.3 has
such wonderful potential with source material that is only going to get better
with time. For driving enthusiasts, there is an F-1 car racing game that makes
you feel like you are really behind the wheel of a Formula-One race car. Even
though the resolution of this game is limited to 720p, the realism is impressive
enough to cause some motion sickness from those watching the race from the driver's
seat on the 100" Stewart filmscreen.
Conclusion
Performance is essential with new HDMI 1.3 components, especially when long
cables are used. Finding a long cable that performed at the higher data rates
was difficult, if not impossible to find until now. VizionWare's Hi
Wirez active cable approach is both innovative and highly effective in delivering
the high bandwidth needed for the latest HDMI signaling requirements that are
largely responsible for achieving the reference picture quality in your home theater.
While the cost of the Hi Wirez cable is more than passive cables, the performance
is clearly (no pun intended) superior from what we have seen. There were absolutely
no image artifacts in any of our source material due to the cabling. In fact,
those who saw the 1080p video in our setup were blown away with the picture quality.
Even the new 1080p games with incredible action at 60 frames per second performed
flawlessly on our screen. If you are tired of dealing with inconsistent and/or
unreliable interconnects in your home theater, you owe it to yourself to go to
the next level with VizionWare's Hi Wirez HDMI cables. It is certainly
money well spent. -
Kevin Nakano | |