|
Epson's
latest entry into the home theater market addresses the need for a low-cost
projector capable of reproducing a quality large-screen picture. The new
PowerLite Home 10 LCD projector is the least expensive of three
new projectors being offered by Epson for home theater. The Home 10 utilizes
three 0.55" wide (16:9), high-aperture LCD panels to produce excellent
color saturation, color accuracy and efficiency. The native resolution
is 854x480, resulting in true square pixels from the 16:9 pixel array.
The projector can be installed on a coffee table or be ceiling mounted.
The short throw lens has a 1.54x optical zoom that allows it to be placed
practically anywhere in the viewing room. The Home 10 is housed in a silver
and soft white chassis that blends in nicely with today's contemporary
decor. The Home 10 is capable of producing 1000 ANSI Lumens (in the Dynamic
color mode) with a contrast ratio of up to 700:1 (in the Theatre Black
mode). The user-replaceable lamp has a life of 2000-3000 hours depending
upon the mode of operation. All this is available to the consumer for
a mere $1,299.
Setup
The Home 10 is simple to install and setup. Manual focus and zoom levers
are located near the top of the lens assembly. We projected video onto
a 92" diagonal 16:9 Da-Lite High Contrast Cinema Vision Screen.
This gray screen helps to improve black level performance of projectors
with limited contrast. We mounted the unit high above the viewing area
flipping it upside down and using the separate rubber feet that were provided
with the projector. This type of installation is an alternative to having
a standard ceiling mounting bracket. The downside to flipping the projector
and using the rubber feet is it makes it more difficult to adjust the
focus and zoom controls during setup because they are somewhat hidden
under the projector.
We positioned
the projector on a platform well above the viewer and about 13-feet from
the 92" screen. We had plenty of range to adjust to the appropriate
screen size and focus. The color-coded rear panel makes it easier to connect
the cables. The projector must be positioned slightly away from the back
wall to accommodate the cabling.
The projector
responds to a power command with an audible tone, which I found to be
a nice feature. As the projector warms up the image becomes brighter until
a steady-state is reached in approximately one minute. While digital keystone
correction controls are available, it is best not to use them. Digital
keystone adjustments almost always cause some distortions on the image.
The user should always try to adjust the position of the projector to
produce a perfectly rectangular image on the screen to avoid this problem.
We set the
Color Mode to Theater Black and the Color Temperature to Medium.
We were told this would set the color tracking to the factory 6500 °K.
This Color Mode also enables the Cinema Filter for the best results when
viewing movies in a dark environment. The top of the projector also has
buttons for controlling the projector settings. Full menu controls are
available for navigation of the available options. Power and Warning light
indicators are also provided on the chassis for power status and warning
conditions (lamp problems, overheating, etc.).
Both the
lamp as well as the air filter are user-replaceable components. Removal
and installation are simple. All Epson PowerLite projectors come
with a 2-year limited warranty that covers the bulb for 90-days. Two special
services are provided that enable owners to expedite service in the event
the projector needs immediate repair. According to Epson, the projector
can usually be replaced within 48 hours.
Connectivity
The rear panel of the Home 10 includes composite, s-video, component and
RGB, making it compatible with virtually any video product. There's even
a small slot to hold the remote control when transporting the projector.
We connected video sources to both the component (RCA x 3) and RGB (15-pin)
video inputs. We also used the s-video, but spent little time with the
composite input. One thing to note is that this projector does not have
a digital input. This should come as no surprise given the unbelievably
low price of ths projector. The 3 RCA jacks labeled "component"
are used for component video, but can also be configured for RGB video
with sync-on-green. This input accepts 480i, 480p, 575i, 575p, 720p and
1080i video inputs. The 15-pin D-sub is for RGB inputs and supports all
of the scan rates the component input supports as well as PC scan rates/resolutions
(VGA, SVGA and XGA) and many MAC modes. The higher resolution modes must
be internally scaled to the native resolution of this projector. The composite
and s-video inputs are fully compatible with NTSC, PAL or SECAM standards.
A pair of audio inputs are also provided in applications where this might
be used with a computer system.
Remote
Control
The small remote resembles the type that comes with your camcorder and
is certainly not what most consumers would like to see in a user interface.
While the rear slot of the projector accommodates the remote so that it
doesn't get lost, I would much rather have a real remote for controlling
the inputs of the projector. Not only is the remote easy to lose, it's
difficult to use in a poorly lit room where the projector performs best.
If you happen to own a Philips Pronto or similar remote control, it would
serve you well to program it with the Home 10 IR commands.
Menus
The menu controls follow a logical format with four main categories (Image,
Setting, Info, and Reset). The Image menu
has controls for adjusting Picture Quality (Brightness, Contrast, Color,
Tint, Sharpness, Color Temperature, and Flesh Tone), Color Mode (Dynamic,
Living Room, Theater or Theater Black), Memory (Save/Recall Image menu
settings to Memory1 or Memory2), and Reset.
The Setting
menu selects the Screen, Operation, On Screen Display, Input Signal, Volume,
Language, and Reset. There's a Screen sub-menu to adjust horizontal
and vertical positioning, vertical keystone, projector position (front/rear,
floor/ceiling), and black Level (0 or 7.5 IRE). There's also an Operation
sub-menu to adjust the sleep mode and child lock features. The On Screen
Display sub-menu allows adjustment of background color and turns the
startup screen on or off. The Input Signal sub-menu allows the
user to configure the input type for the Video Signals (NTSC/PAL/SECAM)
or Input A (YPbPr or RGB with sync on green).
The Information
Menu displays the Lamp Hours, Video Source, Signal Type, and resolution/timing
information if available. Finally, the Reset Menu allows the user to reset
the lamp hours (after bulb replacement), memory for projector settings,
or all settings back to the factory default.
Color
Tracking
We
took measurements directly from the projector using our Sencore CP5000
color analyzer and VP300 video generator connected to the component video
inputs. Using 480p video, we set the black level using the PLUGE pattern
and checked the stair step levels to ensure we had properly adjusted the
display. Using the menu settings we selected the Theater Black
Color Mode and set the Color Temperature to Medium. We measured
the color temperature in 10 IRE increments starting with 20 IRE. The 6500
°K setting was very close to ideal across all measured IRE levels
with only a small deviation from the ideal color temperature. According
the Epson, there are no service menu controls that allow a calibrator
to adjust the display beyond the user settings. This was not necessary
in our case since the projector appears to have accurate color temperature
at all measured IRE levels.
Display
Primaries
We measured the primary colors produced by the Home 10 using the GretagMacbeth
Eye-One Pro Spectrophotometer and ColorFacts System from Milori Software.
Data was taken directly off of our Stewart FireHawk filmscreen. The CIE
chart shows where the ideal primaries are located with the smaller three
points making a dark triangle. The measured primary colors have the red,
green and blue markers connected together with the white triangle. Only
colors inside the white triangle can be produced by the display. The Home
10 colors looked great and produced accurate flesh tones with excellent
color saturation. Primary red was near perfect with both blue and green
close to ideal colors.
Performance
This projector is rather amazing considering its price. While it is limited
to DVD resolution, the price and performance certainly make it attractive.
However, we did immediately notice the Screen Door Effect on this
projector. It must be noted that all digital projectors suffer from this
issue to varying degrees. This projector was more obvious for two reasons.
The fill factor for LCD technology is typically less than what
we've seen with DLP-based projectors. As the fill factor decreases,
the gaps between pixels become more obvious, which increases the Screen
Door Effect. In addition, the lower resolution also increases the
probability of seeing the space between pixels. However, this didn't prevent
the projector from producing an impressive picture in our theater room.
Decreasing screen size or sitting farther from the screen will help reduce
this problem. One advantage of LCD-based projectors like the Home 10 is
the lack of the Rainbow Effect encountered with all single-chip
DLP-based projectors. This can be distracting for many viewers, so it's
best to see both technologies before committing to one type.
Upon power-up,
the projector produced little noise from the cooling fan. In fact, it's
one of the quietest projectors we've heard in our home theater room. Scaling
of the incoming video was very good. Even 1024x768 computer video looked
decent with some loss of resolution. Some deinterlacing artifacts could
be seem with various movies running in the 480i mode. Using 480p video
helped significantly since the deinterlacing was performed by our Faroudja-based
DVD changer. The aspect ratio control selects between 4:3 and 16:9 when
480i or 480p video is sent to the projector. The Home 10 automatically
displays video in the 16:9 mode when 720p or 1080i video is received.
Using the
component video inputs, we connected our JVC HM-DH30000U D-Theater D-VHS
VCR. We looked at several HD-Net tapes and the picture quality was simply
amazing for a projector in this price range. Color were well saturated
and the resolution was good considering the limitations of this projector.
We also tested over-the-air high definition content from our RCA DTC100
using the analog RGB interface. We watched several HD shows and the performance
was equally impressive.
The Dynamic
and Living Room color modes work well in situations where ambient
room light cannot be controlled. However, this mode adversely affects
the black level and is not recommended for serious movie watching. In
addition, gray-scale performance was also affected by these modes. The
Theater Black color mode clearly performed the best for us. Dark
scenes had impressive shadow detail while still maintaining good black
levels. While it's a far cry from the best CRT and latest DLP HD2+ projectors,
the Home 10 performed very well given its price.
Conclusion
The Epson PowerLite Home 10 is a remarkable achievement given its
low price and great performance. While the Home 10 does have some limitations,
such as resolution and contrast ratio, it does produce an impressive picture
from a wide variety of video sources. Its ability to accept 480i, 480p,
575i, 575p, 720p and 1080i with exceptional scaling performance makes
this projector an excellent choice for any home theater on a budget. When
mated to a quality screen and a good progressive scan DVD player, the
performance of the Home 10 is maximized. We were particularly impressed
with the color tracking right out of the box and amazed to see the factory
settings produce a steady 6500 °K color temperature across all IRE
levels. The low noise level was also a great benefit. Anyone on a budget
who is looking at large screen projection systems should spend some time
with this projector.
- Kevin Nakano
Special
Note: Epson
has introduced the new Home 10+ projector that basically offers the same
features found on the original model, but with 200 more ANSI lumens (now
1200) and an increase in maximum contrast ratio from 700:1 to 800:1.
|