|
Over
twenty-five years ago I recall visiting a local high-end audio store and
hearing an M&K system for the first time. This rare setup consisted
of a pair of satellite speakers and a subwoofer. The sound was incredibly
clean and the subwoofer blended seamlessly with the main speakers. Today,
M&K offers a wide selection of both THX and non-THX speakers with
the same basic concept of separate satellite speakers and subwoofer. They
also have a large selection of professional products found in studios
across the country including Dolby Laboratories, Digital Theater Systems,
and the THX division of Lucas Films Ltd.
We recently
had the opportunity to review an S-125 speaker system which included a
pair of S-125s and an S-125C magnetically shielded center channel. The
surrounds consisted of the THX-Ultra certified SS-150THX tripole speakers.
The bass was handled by the MX-125 Mk II subwoofer. The front pair of
S-125s sat on top of a pair of LDM-125 speaker stands which brought the
center of the front two channels right to ear level. All five channels
were driven by our Parasound HCA-2205AT five channel THX-Ultra power amplifier
as well as the Parasound AVC-2500U THX-Ultra A/V controller. We used a
variety of source material including two channel SACD, DVD 96KHz/24-bit
Super Audio Disc, Dolby Digital 5.1 and DTS 5.1 to evaluate this system.
The
S-125
The S-125 speakers are tall and thin measuring just over 6" wide
with the drivers setup in a line. The front pair of the S-125 speakers
are angled slightly inward toward the listener to improve imaging. As
with any speaker pair, the angles of the left and right speakers need
to be tweaked to optimize the soundstage. The center channel is also angled
downward for better on-axis response when placed on top of a rear-screen
television. The front baffle of the S-125 is not parallel with the rear
of the cabinet, nor is the sides completely parallel. This trapezoidal
design helps improve the sonic qualities of the S-125 by preventing sound
from bouncing back and forth inside the cabinet.
Parallel
surfaces tend maximize the slap echo effect, so M&K chose to minimize
this with their cabinet design. Other M&K speakers such as the S-85
(used as mains or surrounds) and SS-150THX surrounds use the same drivers
as the S-125 to achieve a matched timbre for seamless panning of sound
from front to back.
The S-125 driver
arrangement has two 5-1/4" adjacent woofers with a single tweeter
next to them. This is different than the more common D'Apollito (woofer-tweeter-woofer)
configuration frequently seen in the industry. The center channel (S-125C)
exhibited detailed and articulate qualities over a very wide listening
angle making it ideal for the many seating positions in a home theater
environment. M&K claims the Phase-Focused crossover has much to do
with this wide listening window. Many speakers I've listened to have a
sweet spot with a lobing effect as the listener is moved off-axis. These
speakers had a surprisingly uniform off-axis response.
The back of the S-125
has two sets of inputs for selecting either the Normal or Bright
Midrange Timbre crossover characteristics. According to M&K, the
Normal mode follows their Q-curve response, which is said to have
an extremely musical tonal balance. The alternative Bright Midrange
Timbre input is a tonal characteristic more suited for absorptive
room environments much like what is found in many movie theaters. Our
listening environment worked best with the Normal mode, so we used
this for the majority of our listening tests.
SS-150THX
M&K provided us
with their THX-Ultra approved surrounds for this review. The SS-150THX
surrounds are sonically matched with the S-125 front channels. This matched
timbre brings a smooth continuity to sound as it moves throughout the
room. The front baffle of the SS-150THX consists of a single 1" dome
tweeter and single 5-1/4" woofer which when combined, handles the
mid-bass to high frequencies. In addition, the SS-150THX houses a single
3-1/2" driver on each side of the cabinet with one firing forward
while the other fires backwards. These smaller drivers increase the diffused
surround field.
We tried both the
dipole and tripole modes to hear the sonic differences. What we found
was depending on the source material one configuration worked better than
the other. When the rear material was more ambient in nature, we liked
the dipole mode. Sound didn't appear to come directly from the surround
speaker, but rather spread around and behind us. In contrast, DVD-Audio
5.1 and DTS 5.1 material sounded the best when we ran the speaker in the
Tripole mode. This gave us the best timbre match with the front speakers.
Ideally we would like to have five identical channels for most of the
DVD-Audio and DTS music we listened to. However, the tripole mode radiates
sound from the front as well as the sides for the best of both worlds.
We currently have our surrounds setup in the tripole mode and it works
very well for almost all material.
MX-125
MKII
M&K's MX-125 subwoofer
houses two long-throw 12" woofers in a push-pull configuration. These
are the same drivers used in the THX-Ultra certified MX-350 MkII subwoofer.
This design has one driver facing into the room while the second driver
faces up into the bottom of the cabinet. Both drivers are wired electrically
out of phase, but acoustically in phase with one another, doubling the
amount of acoustical power into the room. According to M&K, this push-pull
speaker configuration virtually eliminates even-harmonic distortion by
canceling out driver non-linearities. The rear panel has a control for
setting the low-pass filter crossover frequency as well as a bypass switch
for systems that use a THX processor. In addition, there is a switch for
controlling the phase of the subwoofer (zero or 180 degrees). This can
be particularly useful in maximizing the bass output based on the placement
of the subwoofer in the room.
The bass we experienced
with the MX-125 MkII was clean, articulate and powerful. The dual driver
design is largely responsible for the high output capability of this subwoofer.
The Active Headroom Maximizer circuit that M&K has employed in this
subwoofer design prevents the all too common clipping associated with
overdriving. We didn't use the internal low-pass filter because our THX
processor took care of this for use. One nice thing about using a THX
processor is the satellite speakers and subwoofer are in phase at the
80Hz crossover frequency. As a result, the subwoofer blended in very nicely
with the S-125 front channels. The only issue that may raise concern is
the possibility of magnetic interference due to the lack of magnetic shielding.
This was not a problem for us with our 58" RPTV, but direct view
monitors may be more sensitive.
System Performance
Imaging was superb with two-channel source material. Livingston Taylor's
Isn't She Lovely on Chesky's 24/96 Test DVD revealed details not
previously heard. We found the S-125 characteristics a bit on the bright
side, but without any distortion or fatigue even at high levels. We were
also impressed with the detail and accuracy we heard from our two-channel
SACD sample material. One of my favorite DTS 5.1 cuts is Nineteen
from Steely Dan's Gaucho release. The S-125s played this incredibly
loud without a trace of harshness.
Movies were equally
enjoyable with this speaker system. We used the introduction scene from
Saving Private Ryan as a test and due to the aggressive surround
material and deep bass, felt like we were right there on the beach. Not
a pretty place to be. Whether it was the bullets whizzing by, the impact
of explosions, or subtle low-level sounds, the M&K S-125 speaker system
had the uncanny ability to provide us with an incredible and realistic
experience.
We really enjoyed
these speakers over the past couple of months. The performance of the
S-125 trio, SS-150THX surrounds and the MX-125 MkII subwoofer proved to
be a complete and satisfying sonic experience for both music and home
theater. This system was excellent and we consider them to be some of
the best sounding in their price range. The great sound coupled with the
solid build quality and ten year warranty (5 years on the subwoofer amplifier)
offered by M&K, makes this system difficult to beat. If you're looking
for a speaker system that performs extremely well in both music and home
theater, run to your local dealer and listen for yourself. You won't be
disappointed .
- Kevin Nakano
Review System:
Display: Pioneer Elite PRO-610HD 58-inch HD-Ready TV ISF calibrated.
Set-top Box : Panasonic TU-HDS20 HDTV/DSS Satellite Receiver.
Dish: RCA DSA8900E DirecTV Plus Elliptical dish.
Preamp/Processor: Parasound AVC-2500U DTS/DD Preamp/Processor.
Amplification: Parasound HCA-2205AT THX-Ultra Five Channel Amplifier.
DVD/CD/SACD Player : Sony DVP-S9000ES DVD/CD/SACD Player.
Room
Treatments : Echo Buster panels and Bass Buster towers.
Audio
Analyzer: Sencore SP295 Audio Analyzer.
|